Best Islay Whiskies 2023

Here are out top picks for the best Islay Whiskies in 2023.

Islay whiskies are renowned worldwide for their distinct characteristics, imbued with the soul of a Scottish island rich in history, wind, and sea.

These whiskies often have strong peaty notes, influenced by the rugged coastline and salty sea breezes. For those seeking the heart of Scottish spirit, Islay whiskies offer a tapestry of tastes that remain unparalleled.

Here, we unravel the mystery and unveil the best Islay whisky choices for enthusiasts and newcomers alike.

1. Ardbeg Uigeadail

Named after the loch which supplies the distillery's peat-laden water, Ardbeg Uigeadail is a celebration of intensity.

It blends Ardbeg’s traditional deep smoke notes with the luscious, raisin tones of old ex-sherry casks.

This whisky is non-chill filtered, boasting a strength of 54.2% ABV. With a finish that's long and warming, Uigeadail is a whisky for those who want a full-bodied experience.

Tasting notes: Multi-layered aromas ranging from sweet and spicy, to deep smoke, peat and dark fruit undertones.

2. Laphroaig 10 Year Old

One cannot talk about top Islay whiskies without mentioning Laphroaig 10. It's a classic for good reason.

This single malt scotch whisky offers an explosion of peaty smoke, underlined by a touch of sweetness and a hint of the sea.

Matured in seasoned oak barrels, it offers an adventurous journey for the palate.

Tasting notes: Seaweed and smokiness at the forefront, followed by a surprising sweetness and hints of salt and layers of peatiness.

3. Lagavulin 16 Year Old

Lagavulin 16 is often the benchmark for Islay whiskies, renowned for its profound smoky character.

Aged for 16 years, it's a deep, dry and exceptionally peaty bruiser, yet it is also balanced with a touch of rich fruitiness.

Tasting notes: Strong notes of dense smoke and iodine, complemented by a rich sherried sweetness and a touch of dried fruit.

4. Caol Ila 12 Year Old

Caol Ila is perhaps the most understated distillery on Islay, but its 12-year-old whisky is a masterpiece in its own right.

It provides a lighter, more approachable introduction to the smoky whiskies of the region.

Tasting notes: Lighter peatiness with hints of citrus and a refreshing sea breeze finish.

5. Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie

This unpeated whisky offers a twist in the traditional Islay narrative. Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie is crafted from 100% Scottish barley and is a testament to the craftsmanship at the Bruichladdich distillery.

It is floral, fruity, and exceedingly fresh.

Tasting notes: Notes of malted barley, fresh wildflowers, a touch of mint and briny character.

6. Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old

Bunnahabhain stands out as it offers a more approachable, less peaty experience compared to other Islay whiskies.

The 12 Year Old, with its sherried, nutty flavors, is a gentle introduction to the Islay style, particularly suitable for those who prefer a milder profile.

Tasting notes: Nutty and rich, with hints of seaweed, light fruitiness, and a touch of spice.

Top Pick: Ardbeg Uigeadail

Out of the numerous contenders, Ardbeg Uigeadail claims the throne. This whisky stands out not just for its intense flavors, but also for its complexity and depth.

Every sip offers a harmonious blend of smoke, peat, and sherry sweetness, making it an outstanding representation of what Islay has to offer.

Final thoughts...

Islay whiskies remain a symbol of tradition, nature, and craftsmanship. Each distillery on this island offers a unique tale of flavor and history, making the search for the best Islay whisky a thrilling adventure.

Whether you’re seeking the smokiest of drams or a lighter, fruitier note, Islay promises a spectrum of tastes that continue to captivate whisky lovers around the globe.

Remember, while these are some of the best, your perfect Islay whisky is the one that suits your palate. So, embark on this spirited journey and discover the depth and breadth of top Islay whiskies today.

Note: Prices and availability of the whiskies mentioned might vary depending on your region. Always drink responsibly.